valyzer
Politics · Judicial ruling

ES Philippine Supreme Court declares the 2024 and 2025 budgets unconstitutional because Congress raised spending above what the president proposed

The Philippine Supreme Court published on October 20 a ruling, dated October 7, declaring unconstitutional the 2024 (RA 11975) and 2025 (RA 12116) budget laws because Congress raised total spending above what President Marcos proposed: 449.5 billion pesos (7.12 billion dollars) added to the 2024 unprogrammed appropriations and 17.99 billion to the 2025 Special Road Fund. The court also voided provisions on unprogrammed funds in the 2026 budget and the 2024 and 2025 SAGIP items, which it considered prohibited lump-sum appropriations. Unprogrammed funds are not unconstitutional in themselves, but they need clear limits and safeguards. Under the operative fact doctrine, spending already executed is recognized and its return is not ordered. Opposition lawmakers have appealed.

Technical recordView JSON in the API (opens in a new tab)ID e72e7dcc-0d2c-4a55-bd89-af2ded042f63

Place: Manila

View the country context in World →

Occurred
20 Oct 2026, 00:00 UTC
Last updated by Valyzer
Severity
Medium
Confidence
50%
Verification
Automated verification (no editorial review)
Quality
No warnings
Evidence pieces
1

Confidence (50 %) estimates the strength of the reading; it does not substitute for verification.

Related entities

Facts

Fact

El Tribunal Supremo de Filipinas declara inconstitucionales los presupuestos de 2024 y 2025 porque el Congreso elevó el gasto por encima de lo propuesto por el presidente

Confidence 50%

Evidence for the claim

Relationships and impacts

Observed connections are separate from inferred impact mechanisms.

Observed relationships

No evidenced relationships have been published for this event.

Inferred impacts

Potential scenarios, not confirmed facts.

Documented participation; impact undetermined

These records identify participants in the act. They do not establish a positive or negative consequence on their own.

Philippines

Evidence for participation

No impact mechanisms have been published for this event.

Sources consulted

Deduplicated evidence pieces behind this event. Sources are repeated only in the blocks that cite them.

Evolution and evidence

Browse what changed and what Valyzer knew at the selected cut. Comparisons use explicit versions, not page order.

Valid at
Known until
Reset
  1. Correction

    Recorded

    Public reason: Public reason unavailable

    Validity
    — current

    Event

  2. Correction

    Recorded

    Public reason: Public reason unavailable

    Validity
    — current

    Event

  3. Publication

    Recorded

    Public reason: Public reason unavailable

    Validity
    — current